Philip Morris Asia Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia
Restructuring an investment to obtain treaty protection when a specific dispute is foreseeable is an abuse of rights, so the challenge to Australia's tobacco plain packaging laws was inadmissible.
Facts
In April 2010, the Australian government announced that it would introduce plain packaging for tobacco products, and the legislation was passed in 2011. In February 2011, the Philip Morris group restructured its Australian operations so that its Australian subsidiary became owned by Philip Morris Asia, a company incorporated in Hong Kong. Philip Morris Asia then brought a claim under the Hong Kong Australia bilateral investment treaty, alleging that plain packaging expropriated its investment and breached the fair and equitable treatment standard.
Legal principle
The tribunal held that the claim was inadmissible because the initiation of the arbitration was an abuse of rights. The main and determinative reason for the restructuring had been to obtain protection under the treaty for a dispute which was foreseeable at the time, since the government had already announced its intention to introduce plain packaging. Restructuring an investment to obtain treaty protection is not illegitimate in itself, but it is an abuse where it is done when a specific dispute is foreseeable, meaning that there is a reasonable prospect that a measure giving rise to a treaty claim will materialise. Philip Morris was later ordered to pay a substantial part of Australia's costs. The outcome, together with Philip Morris Brands Sàrl v Oriental Republic of Uruguay, was important for tobacco control worldwide.
Related cases on Treaty shopping, abuse of process and intra EU disputes
- Aguas del Tunari SA v Republic of Bolivia ICSID Case No ARB/02/3, Decision on Jurisdiction (2005)
- CME Czech Republic BV v Czech Republic UNCITRAL Partial Award (2001)
- Commission v United Kingdom (Micula) Case C-516/22 (2024)
- Mobil Corp v Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela ICSID Case No ARB/07/27, Decision on Jurisdiction (2010)
- Pac Rim Cayman LLC v Republic of El Salvador ICSID Case No ARB/09/12, Decision on Jurisdictional Objections (2012)
- Republic of Moldova v Komstroy LLC Case C-741/19, EU:C:2021:655
- Republic of Poland v PL Holdings Sàrl Case C-109/20, EU:C:2021:875
- Slovak Republic v Achmea BV Case C-284/16, EU:C:2018:158
Studying international investment law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
