Philip Morris Brands Sàrl v Oriental Republic of Uruguay
Uruguay's tobacco control measures, including large graphic health warnings and a single presentation requirement, were a valid exercise of its police powers to protect public health and were neither an expropriation nor a breach of fair and equitable treatment.
Facts
Uruguay adopted measures to reduce smoking, including a requirement that each brand of cigarettes be sold in a single presentation, which ended variants such as Marlboro Gold and Marlboro Blue, and a requirement that health warnings cover 80 per cent of the front and back of cigarette packets. Companies in the Philip Morris group, which were incorporated in Switzerland, claimed under the Switzerland Uruguay bilateral investment treaty that the measures expropriated their trade marks and goodwill and breached the fair and equitable treatment standard.
Legal principle
The tribunal, by a majority, dismissed all the claims and ordered the claimants to pay Uruguay's costs. The measures were not an expropriation, because the claimants' business retained substantial value, and in any event the measures were a valid exercise of Uruguay's police powers for the protection of public health, adopted in good faith, non discriminatory and proportionate to their objective. They did not breach the fair and equitable treatment standard, since they were based on scientific evidence and the World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, and states have a wide margin of appreciation in matters of public health. Gary Born dissented on the single presentation requirement and on a denial of justice claim. The award is a landmark in the recognition of the state's right to regulate.
Related cases on expropriation
- Bear Creek Mining Corp v Republic of Peru ICSID Case No ARB/14/21, Award (2017)
- Compañía del Desarrollo de Santa Elena SA v Republic of Costa Rica ICSID Case No ARB/96/1, Award (2000)
- Metalclad Corp v United Mexican States ICSID Case No ARB(AF)/97/1, Award (2000)
- Methanex Corp v United States of America NAFTA Final Award (2005)
- Occidental Petroleum Corp v Republic of Ecuador ICSID Case No ARB/06/11, Award (2012)
- Saipem SpA v People's Republic of Bangladesh ICSID Case No ARB/05/7, Award (2009)
- Texaco Overseas Petroleum Co v Libyan Arab Republic (1977) 17 ILM 1
- Técnicas Medioambientales Tecmed SA v United Mexican States ICSID Case No ARB(AF)/00/2, Award (2003)
Studying international investment law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
