Republic of Moldova v Komstroy LLC
The investor state arbitration provision in the Energy Charter Treaty does not apply to disputes between a member state and an investor from another member state, and the purchase of a debt for electricity is not an investment under the treaty.
Facts
Energoalians, a Ukrainian company, sold electricity to a Moldovan state owned company and later assigned the resulting debt to Komstroy, a Ukrainian company. Komstroy brought an arbitration against Moldova under the Energy Charter Treaty, with its seat in Paris, and obtained an award in its favour. Moldova sought to annul the award in the French courts, and the Paris Court of Appeal referred questions to the Court of Justice about the meaning of investment under the treaty.
Legal principle
The Court of Justice held that the acquisition of a claim arising from a contract for the supply of electricity, which did not involve any contribution by the investor in the host state, was not an investment within the Energy Charter Treaty. It also held, although this was not necessary to answer the question referred, that article 26(2)(c) of the treaty must be interpreted as not being applicable to disputes between a member state and an investor of another member state concerning an investment made by the latter in the first member state, applying the reasoning in Slovak Republic v Achmea BV, since such arbitration would remove disputes about EU law from the EU judicial system. The ruling deepened the conflict between EU law and intra EU investment arbitration, and the EU later withdrew from the Energy Charter Treaty.
Related cases on Treaty shopping, abuse of process and intra EU disputes
- Aguas del Tunari SA v Republic of Bolivia ICSID Case No ARB/02/3, Decision on Jurisdiction (2005)
- CME Czech Republic BV v Czech Republic UNCITRAL Partial Award (2001)
- Commission v United Kingdom (Micula) Case C-516/22 (2024)
- Mobil Corp v Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela ICSID Case No ARB/07/27, Decision on Jurisdiction (2010)
- Pac Rim Cayman LLC v Republic of El Salvador ICSID Case No ARB/09/12, Decision on Jurisdictional Objections (2012)
- Philip Morris Asia Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia PCA Case No 2012-12, Award on Jurisdiction and Admissibility (2015)
- Republic of Poland v PL Holdings Sàrl Case C-109/20, EU:C:2021:875
- Slovak Republic v Achmea BV Case C-284/16, EU:C:2018:158
Studying international investment law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
