Republic of Poland v PL Holdings Sàrl
A member state cannot avoid the ruling in Achmea by concluding an ad hoc arbitration agreement with an investor in the same terms as an invalid intra EU investment treaty clause.
Facts
PL Holdings, a company incorporated in Luxembourg, owned shares in two Polish banks. The Polish financial supervision authority suspended its voting rights and ordered the sale of the shares. PL Holdings began arbitration under the Belgium Luxembourg Poland bilateral investment treaty, and Poland did not object to the tribunal's jurisdiction in time under the arbitration rules. The tribunal made an award against Poland, and Poland challenged it in the Swedish courts, which referred the question whether an arbitration agreement could be inferred from Poland's conduct, despite the invalidity of the treaty clause under Slovak Republic v Achmea BV.
Legal principle
The Court of Justice held that articles 267 and 344 TFEU preclude national legislation which allows a member state to conclude an ad hoc arbitration agreement with an investor from another member state which makes it possible to continue arbitral proceedings initiated on the basis of an arbitration clause in an intra EU investment treaty which is invalid, where the agreement has the same content as that clause. Such an agreement would perpetuate the effects of the invalid clause and circumvent the obligations arising from EU law, and the national court is required to uphold an application to set aside an award made on that basis. The ruling extended the reach of Achmea to arbitration based on implied consent.
Related cases on Treaty shopping, abuse of process and intra EU disputes
- Aguas del Tunari SA v Republic of Bolivia ICSID Case No ARB/02/3, Decision on Jurisdiction (2005)
- CME Czech Republic BV v Czech Republic UNCITRAL Partial Award (2001)
- Commission v United Kingdom (Micula) Case C-516/22 (2024)
- Mobil Corp v Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela ICSID Case No ARB/07/27, Decision on Jurisdiction (2010)
- Pac Rim Cayman LLC v Republic of El Salvador ICSID Case No ARB/09/12, Decision on Jurisdictional Objections (2012)
- Philip Morris Asia Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia PCA Case No 2012-12, Award on Jurisdiction and Admissibility (2015)
- Republic of Moldova v Komstroy LLC Case C-741/19, EU:C:2021:655
- Slovak Republic v Achmea BV Case C-284/16, EU:C:2018:158
Studying international investment law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
