Metalclad Corp v United Mexican States
Measures which deprived an investor of the use and reasonably expected economic benefit of its hazardous waste landfill amounted to an indirect expropriation under article 1110 of NAFTA.
Facts
Metalclad, a United States company, acquired a Mexican company which owned a hazardous waste landfill site in the municipality of Guadalcázar, in the state of San Luis Potosí. Metalclad built the landfill after receiving federal permits and assurances that no other permits were needed, but the municipality refused it a construction permit, and the state governor later issued an ecological decree declaring the area a protected zone for the conservation of a rare cactus. The landfill never opened, and Metalclad brought a claim under Chapter 11 of NAFTA.
Legal principle
The tribunal held that Mexico had breached the minimum standard of treatment in article 1105, by failing to provide a transparent and predictable framework for Metalclad's investment, and had indirectly expropriated the investment in breach of article 1110. Expropriation includes not only open and deliberate takings of property, but also covert or incidental interference with the use of property which has the effect of depriving the owner of the use or reasonably expected economic benefit of the property. Mexico was ordered to pay about 16.7 million US dollars. On a challenge in British Columbia, where the arbitration was seated, the Supreme Court of British Columbia set aside the parts of the award based on transparency but upheld the finding that the ecological decree was an expropriation.
Related cases on expropriation
- Bear Creek Mining Corp v Republic of Peru ICSID Case No ARB/14/21, Award (2017)
- Compañía del Desarrollo de Santa Elena SA v Republic of Costa Rica ICSID Case No ARB/96/1, Award (2000)
- Methanex Corp v United States of America NAFTA Final Award (2005)
- Occidental Petroleum Corp v Republic of Ecuador ICSID Case No ARB/06/11, Award (2012)
- Philip Morris Brands Sàrl v Oriental Republic of Uruguay ICSID Case No ARB/10/7, Award (2016)
- Saipem SpA v People's Republic of Bangladesh ICSID Case No ARB/05/7, Award (2009)
- Texaco Overseas Petroleum Co v Libyan Arab Republic (1977) 17 ILM 1
- Técnicas Medioambientales Tecmed SA v United Mexican States ICSID Case No ARB(AF)/00/2, Award (2003)
Studying international investment law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
