Técnicas Medioambientales Tecmed SA v United Mexican States
The refusal to renew a permit for a hazardous waste landfill was an indirect expropriation, and the tribunal assessed regulatory measures by asking whether they were proportionate to the public interest pursued.
Facts
Tecmed, a Spanish company, acquired through a Mexican subsidiary a hazardous waste landfill near Hermosillo, in the state of Sonora. The operating permit was granted for one year, renewable annually. After local opposition to the landfill grew, the federal environmental authority refused to renew the permit, and the landfill had to close. Tecmed brought a claim under the Spain Mexico bilateral investment treaty.
Legal principle
The tribunal held that the refusal to renew the permit was an indirect expropriation, because it permanently and irreversibly deprived Tecmed of the economic use and enjoyment of its investment. In deciding whether a regulatory measure is expropriatory, the tribunal considered whether it was proportionate to the public interest it was intended to protect and to the protection legally granted to investments, and found that the refusal was driven largely by political pressure rather than by genuine environmental concerns or serious breaches of the permit. The tribunal also held that Mexico had breached the fair and equitable treatment standard, stating that the standard requires the host state to act consistently, free from ambiguity and totally transparently, so that the investor may know in advance the rules that will govern its investment. That broad statement of the investor's legitimate expectations has been influential but much criticised.
Related cases on expropriation
- Bear Creek Mining Corp v Republic of Peru ICSID Case No ARB/14/21, Award (2017)
- Compañía del Desarrollo de Santa Elena SA v Republic of Costa Rica ICSID Case No ARB/96/1, Award (2000)
- Metalclad Corp v United Mexican States ICSID Case No ARB(AF)/97/1, Award (2000)
- Methanex Corp v United States of America NAFTA Final Award (2005)
- Occidental Petroleum Corp v Republic of Ecuador ICSID Case No ARB/06/11, Award (2012)
- Philip Morris Brands Sàrl v Oriental Republic of Uruguay ICSID Case No ARB/10/7, Award (2016)
- Saipem SpA v People's Republic of Bangladesh ICSID Case No ARB/05/7, Award (2009)
- Texaco Overseas Petroleum Co v Libyan Arab Republic (1977) 17 ILM 1
Studying international investment law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
