Held v State of Montana
The Montana Supreme Court held that the state's constitutional right to a clean and healthful environment includes a stable climate system, and struck down a law preventing the consideration of greenhouse gas emissions in environmental reviews.
Facts
Sixteen young people challenged a provision of the Montana Environmental Policy Act which prevented state agencies from considering greenhouse gas emissions and their effects on the climate when carrying out environmental reviews of energy projects, such as coal mines and power plants. They argued that the provision violated the right to a clean and healthful environment guaranteed by the Montana Constitution. The trial court held, after a trial at which expert evidence about climate change was heard, that the provision was unconstitutional.
Legal principle
The Montana Supreme Court, by a majority, affirmed the decision. The right to a clean and healthful environment in the Montana Constitution includes a stable climate system that sustains human lives and liberties, and the provision of the Act, which prevented agencies from considering greenhouse gas emissions, was subject to strict scrutiny and was not narrowly tailored to serve a compelling state interest. The plaintiffs had standing, because their injuries were caused in part by the state's emissions and could be alleviated by striking down the provision. The case was the first in which a court in the United States held, after a full trial, that a government's climate policy violated constitutional rights.
Related cases on climate change litigation
- Advisory Opinion OC-32/25 on the Climate Emergency and Human Rights (2025) Inter-American Court of Human Rights
- Carvalho v European Parliament and Council of the European Union Case C-565/19 P, EU:C:2021:252
- Carême v France (2024) Application no 7189/21
- Duarte Agostinho v Portugal and 32 Other States (2024) Application no 39371/20
- Future Generations v Ministry of the Environment (2018) STC4360-2018
- Juliana v United States (2020) 947 F 3d 1159
- Leghari v Federation of Pakistan (2015) WP No 25501/2015
- Lliuya v RWE AG (2025) I-5 U 15/17
Studying environmental law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
