Carvalho v European Parliament and Council of the European Union
In the People's Climate Case, the Court of Justice held that individuals affected by climate change were not individually concerned by EU climate legislation, so they lacked standing to challenge it.
Facts
Families from several member states and from outside the EU, whose livelihoods were affected by climate change, together with an association of young indigenous Sami people, brought an action for the annulment of EU legislation setting greenhouse gas emission reduction targets for 2030, which they argued were insufficient to protect their fundamental rights. The General Court dismissed the action as inadmissible, because the applicants were not individually concerned by the legislation. The applicants appealed, arguing that the test for standing should be relaxed where fundamental rights are infringed.
Legal principle
The Court of Justice dismissed the appeal. Applying the test in Plaumann & Co v Commission, it held that the applicants were not individually concerned, because the fact that the effects of climate change may be different for one person than for another does not mean that a measure of general application individually concerns each of them. The claim that an act infringes fundamental rights is not enough in itself to establish standing, since otherwise the requirements of article 263 TFEU would be rendered meaningless, and the court could not set aside the conditions laid down by the Treaty. The case confirms the restrictive approach to the standing of private applicants, despite criticism in the context of climate change.
Related cases on Judicial review and actions against EU institutions
- Aktien-Zuckerfabrik Schöppenstedt v Council Case 5/71, [1971] ECR 975
- Codorníu SA v Council Case C-309/89, [1994] ECR I-1853
- Commission v France (Fishery products) Case C-304/02, [2005] ECR I-6263
- Commission v Jégo-Quéré & Cie SA Case C-263/02 P, [2004] ECR I-3425
- Germany v European Parliament and Council (Tobacco Advertising) Case C-376/98, [2000] ECR I-8419
- Hungary v European Parliament and Council of the European Union Case C-156/21, EU:C:2022:97
- Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami v European Parliament and Council Case C-583/11 P, EU:C:2013:625
- Laboratoires Pharmaceutiques Bergaderm SA v Commission Case C-352/98 P, [2000] ECR I-5291
Studying EU Law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
