Zabolotnyi v Mateszalka District Court, Hungary

There is no heightened test for admitting evidence that a requesting state has breached assurances about prison conditions given to another state, but such evidence must be cogent to rebut the presumption that the state will comply.

Citation
[2021] UKSC 14
Court
UK Supreme Court
Year
2021
Subject
Immigration and Asylum Law
Topic
Extradition

Facts

Hungary sought the extradition of Mr Zabolotnyi under a European Arrest Warrant. He resisted on the ground that conditions in Hungarian prisons, particularly the limited space in cells, would breach article 3 of the ECHR. After the courts had held that assurances were needed for extradition to Hungary, the Hungarian Ministry of Justice gave an assurance about the conditions in which he would be held. On appeal, he sought to rely on fresh evidence of alleged breaches of assurances given to other prisoners extradited from the United Kingdom and Germany, and the Divisional Court applied a heightened test to evidence relating to assurances given to another state.

Legal principle

The Supreme Court held that there was no such heightened test. Lord Lloyd-Jones said that evidence of past breaches of assurances is relevant whether the assurance was given to the United Kingdom or to another state, and is to be assessed in the same way as other evidence, bearing in mind that cogent evidence is needed to rebut the presumption that a member state will comply with its human rights obligations and its assurances. However, the appeal was dismissed, because the fresh evidence was too limited to rebut that presumption and would not have resulted in the judge deciding the question differently, which is the test under section 27 of the Extradition Act 2003.

Related cases on extradition

Studying immigration and asylum law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.

Back to all law cases

This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.

Contact Us

Enquire about our bespoke academic solutions