Whittington Hospital NHS Trust v XX
A woman who lost the ability to bear children because of a hospital's negligence could recover damages for the cost of commercial surrogacy arrangements abroad, where they were lawful, as well as for non commercial surrogacy in the United Kingdom.
Facts
Because of the hospital's negligent failure to detect signs of cervical cancer in smear tests and biopsies, XX's cancer was not diagnosed until it had become invasive, and the treatment she needed left her unable to bear children. She wished to have four children through surrogacy, using her own eggs, which had been frozen, and claimed damages for the cost of commercial surrogacy arrangements in California, where they were lawful, or alternatively of non commercial surrogacy in the United Kingdom, where commercial surrogacy is prohibited.
Legal principle
The Supreme Court held, by a majority, that XX could recover damages for the cost of commercial surrogacy in California, as well as for non commercial surrogacy in the United Kingdom, using either her own eggs or donor eggs. Lady Hale, giving the leading judgment, said that public policy had changed since earlier decisions, because surrogacy was now increasingly recognised as a legitimate way of creating a family, the law already recognised the children born through foreign commercial surrogacy, and it would not be inconsistent with the law to award damages for arrangements which were lawful in the country where they took place. The arrangements had to be reasonable and the costs reasonable. Lord Carnwath and Lord Reed dissented on the commercial surrogacy point.
Related cases on clinical negligence, informed consent and wrongful birth
- Bailey v Ministry of Defence [2008] EWCA Civ 883, [2009] 1 WLR 1052
- Barnett v Chelsea and Kensington Hospital Management Committee [1969] 1 QB 428
- Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] 1 WLR 582
- Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority [1998] AC 232
- Chester v Afshar [2004] UKHL 41, [2005] 1 AC 134
- Darnley v Croydon Health Services NHS Trust [2018] UKSC 50, [2019] AC 831
- Emeh v Kensington and Chelsea and Westminster Area Health Authority [1985] QB 1012
- Gregg v Scott [2005] UKHL 2, [2005] 2 AC 176
Studying medical law and ethics? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
