Stevens v Hotel Portfolio II UK Ltd
A dishonest assistant is liable to compensate the principal for the dissipation of profits held on constructive trust for it, and gains from one breach cannot generally be set off against losses from another.
Facts
Mr Ruhan was a director of Hotel Portfolio II UK Ltd (HPII) and owed it fiduciary duties. In 2005, HPII sold three hotels at their market value to Cambulo, a company of which Mr Stevens was the nominal owner, but both were in fact nominees for Mr Ruhan, who concealed his role. Cambulo later resold the hotels, which had obtained planning permission for residential development, at a large profit, and over £100 million of the profits went to Mr Ruhan, who dissipated them. The High Court held Mr Ruhan liable for breach of fiduciary duty and Mr Stevens liable for dishonestly assisting him, and ordered Mr Stevens to pay £102 million in equitable compensation. The Court of Appeal allowed his appeal, holding that HPII had suffered no compensable loss.
Legal principle
The Supreme Court, by a majority, allowed HPII's appeal. Lord Briggs, with whom Lord Reed, Lord Hamblen and Lord Richards agreed, held that the profits of the resale were held on an institutional constructive trust for HPII from the moment they were received, so their dissipation was a breach of that trust which caused HPII a loss, and Mr Stevens, who had dishonestly assisted in the scheme, was liable to compensate HPII for it. The correct comparison was with the position if the trust fund had not been dissipated, not with the position if the trust had never arisen. The profits from the resale could not be set off against the loss, because the exception to the rule against setting off gains from one breach against losses from another is narrow, applying only where strict application of the rule would be plainly inequitable. Lord Burrows dissented, holding that the scheme should be judged as a whole and that, judged in that way, HPII had suffered no loss.
Related cases on tracing and third party liability
- Agip (Africa) Ltd v Jackson [1991] Ch 547
- Baden v Société Générale pour Favoriser le Développement du Commerce et de l'Industrie en France SA [1993] 1 WLR 509
- Barlow Clowes International Ltd v Eurotrust International Ltd [2005] UKPC 37, [2006] 1 WLR 1476
- Barlow Clowes International Ltd v Vaughan [1992] 4 All ER 22
- BCCI (Overseas) Ltd v Akindele [2001] Ch 437
- Bishopsgate Investment Management Ltd v Homan [1995] Ch 211
- Boscawen v Bajwa [1996] 1 WLR 328
- Byers v Saudi National Bank [2023] UKSC 51
Studying equity and trusts? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
