Starlight Shipping Co v Allianz Marine & Aviation Versicherungs AG (The Alexandros T)
English claims for damages and indemnities under settlement agreements with English jurisdiction clauses did not involve the same cause of action as later tort proceedings in Greece, so they were not stayed.
Facts
The vessel Alexandros T sank off South Africa in 2006. Her owners claimed under hull and machinery policies, which were governed by English law and contained English jurisdiction clauses, and the claims were settled in 2009 under agreements which released the insurers and contained English jurisdiction clauses. The owners then brought proceedings in Greece against the insurers and individuals, alleging in tort under Greek law that they had spread false rumours that the vessel had been deliberately scuttled. The insurers brought claims in England for indemnities and damages under the settlement agreements, and the owners sought a stay under articles 27 and 28 of the Brussels I Regulation.
Legal principle
The Supreme Court held that the English claims for declarations, indemnities and damages under the settlement agreements and for breach of the jurisdiction clauses did not involve the same cause of action as the Greek tort claims, so article 27 did not require the English court to decline jurisdiction, and the English proceedings should continue rather than be stayed under article 28. The court explained that the question whether two sets of proceedings involve the same cause of action is to be answered by comparing the facts and the rules of law relied on, and that claims seeking to enforce the parties' agreement to litigate in England were distinct from the claims in Greece.
Related cases on jurisdiction agreements and anti-suit injunctions
- Airbus Industrie GIE v Patel [1999] 1 AC 119
- Allianz SpA v West Tankers Inc (The Front Comor) Case C-185/07, [2009] ECR I-663
- Benincasa v Dentalkit Srl Case C-269/95, [1997] ECR I-3767
- Deutsche Bank AG v Highland Crusader Offshore Partners LP [2009] EWCA Civ 725
- Donohue v Armco Inc [2001] UKHL 64
- El Majdoub v CarsOnTheWeb.Deutschland GmbH Case C-322/14, EU:C:2015:334
- The Eleftheria [1970] P 94
- Société Nationale Industrielle Aérospatiale v Lee Kui Jak [1987] AC 871
Studying conflict of laws? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
