Scottish Equitable plc v Derby
The recipient of a mistaken overpayment of pension benefits could rely on change of position only for expenditure caused by the receipt, and not for using the money to pay off his mortgage.
Facts
Mr Derby had a pension policy with Scottish Equitable. When he took his benefits, Scottish Equitable, through an administrative error, overlooked the fact that he had transferred part of his pension rights to another scheme, and paid him a lump sum of about 172,000 pounds more than he was entitled to. Mr Derby used most of the money to pay off his mortgage and spent some on modest improvements in his lifestyle. When the mistake was discovered, Scottish Equitable claimed repayment, and Mr Derby relied on the defence of change of position.
Legal principle
The Court of Appeal held that the defence succeeded only to the limited extent of the modest lifestyle expenditure. Robert Walker LJ said that the defence protects a recipient who has changed his position in reliance on the receipt so that it would be inequitable to require repayment, but it does not cover expenditure which the recipient would have incurred anyway, or the use of the money to reduce a debt, because paying off the mortgage meant that he had not lost the benefit of the money. The court rejected the argument that the defence should apply more generally because of the effect of the mistake on his financial planning, in the absence of evidence of real detriment.
Related cases on public authorities, defences and remedies
- Attorney General v Blake [2001] 1 AC 268
- Auckland Harbour Board v The King [1924] AC 318
- BCCI (Overseas) Ltd v Akindele [2001] Ch 437
- Boscawen v Bajwa [1996] 1 WLR 328
- Re Diplock [1948] Ch 465
- Kingstreet Investments Ltd v New Brunswick (Department of Finance) [2007] 1 SCR 3
- Kleinwort Benson Ltd v Birmingham City Council [1997] QB 380
- Littlewoods Ltd v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2017] UKSC 70
Studying restitution and unjust enrichment? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
