Scotch Whisky Association v Lord Advocate
Minimum unit pricing of alcohol is a measure having equivalent effect to a quantitative restriction, which can be justified on health grounds only if a less restrictive measure, such as increased taxation, would not be as effective.
Facts
The Scottish Parliament passed the Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Act 2012, which provided for a minimum price per unit of alcohol for alcoholic drinks sold in Scotland. The Scotch Whisky Association and other trade bodies challenged the legislation, arguing that it was incompatible with EU law, and the Court of Session referred questions to the Court of Justice.
Legal principle
The Court of Justice held that minimum unit pricing was a measure having equivalent effect to a quantitative restriction on imports, because it prevented the lower cost price of imported products from being reflected in the selling price to consumers. It could be justified on grounds of the protection of human health under article 36 TFEU only if it was proportionate, which required it to be shown that a less restrictive measure, such as increased excise duties, would not be capable of protecting health as effectively, a question for the national court to decide on the evidence available at the time of its decision. The Supreme Court later upheld the legislation as proportionate in Scotch Whisky Association v Lord Advocate [2017] UKSC 76.
Related cases on free movement of goods
- Campus Oil Ltd v Minister for Industry and Energy Case 72/83, [1984] ECR 2727
- Commission v Denmark (Danish bottles) Case 302/86, [1988] ECR 4607
- Commission v France (Spanish strawberries) Case C-265/95, [1997] ECR I-6959
- Commission v Germany (Beer purity) Case 178/84, [1987] ECR 1227
- Commission v Ireland (Buy Irish) Case 249/81, [1982] ECR 4005
- Commission v Italy (Art treasures) Case 7/68, [1968] ECR 423
- Commission v Italy (Motorcycle trailers) Case C-110/05, [2009] ECR I-519
- Conegate Ltd v HM Customs & Excise Case 121/85, [1986] ECR 1007
Studying EU Law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
