Saxon Woods Investments Ltd v Costa
The duty of good faith in section 172 of the Companies Act 2006 governs a director's conduct as well as his state of mind, so a director who covertly pursues his own strategy against the board's agreed strategy is in breach.
Facts
Spring Media Investments Ltd was the holding company of a group providing creative services to fashion, beauty and luxury brands. A shareholders' agreement required the company and its investors to work in good faith towards a sale of the business by the end of 2019, and the board delegated the sale process to Mr Costa, a director and chairman who had a substantial indirect interest in the company. Believing that a later sale would produce a better return, Mr Costa delayed the sale beyond 2019, kept the other directors out of the process and gave the board the impression that the agreement was being complied with. The Covid pandemic then destroyed the prospect of a profitable sale. Saxon Woods, which held 22.33 per cent of the shares, petitioned for relief from unfair prejudice. The judge found unfair prejudice but no breach of section 172, and the Court of Appeal held that Mr Costa had breached section 172 by acting dishonestly and ordered an unconditional buy out of Saxon Woods's shares.
Legal principle
The Supreme Court, in a judgment given by Lord Briggs, unanimously dismissed Mr Costa's appeal. The requirement of good faith in section 172 extends to a director's conduct and not only to his thinking, so a director who covertly seeks to subvert the strategy agreed by the board is in breach of the duty, even if he genuinely believes that his own strategy is better for the company. The business judgment principle in Re Smith & Fawcett Ltd protects a director's genuine decisions, but not a covert attempt to override the board's management. It was unnecessary to apply the test for dishonesty in Ivey v Genting Casinos (UK) Ltd, because the fiduciary duty of loyalty provided the framework, and dishonesty was merely evidence of breach. Since the judge's exercise of discretion had rested on a wrong conclusion about section 172, the Court of Appeal was entitled to order an unconditional buy out.
Related cases on directors' duties: powers, judgment and care
- Bamford v Bamford [1970] Ch 212
- Re Barings plc (No 5) [1999] 1 BCLC 433
- BTI 2014 LLC v Sequana SA [2022] UKSC 25, [2024] AC 211
- Charterbridge Corp Ltd v Lloyds Bank Ltd [1970] Ch 62
- Re City Equitable Fire Insurance Co Ltd [1925] Ch 407
- Re D'Jan of London Ltd [1994] 1 BCLC 561
- Dorchester Finance Co Ltd v Stebbing [1989] BCLC 498
- Eclairs Group Ltd v JKX Oil & Gas plc [2015] UKSC 71
Studying company law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
