Revenue and Customs Commissioners v Atholl House Productions Ltd
In deciding whether a presenter working through her own company would have been an employee of the BBC under a hypothetical contract, the tribunal must consider the terms of that contract and circumstances known to both parties.
Facts
Kaye Adams, a well known broadcaster, presented a programme on BBC Radio Scotland through her personal service company, Atholl House Productions. HMRC decided that the intermediaries legislation, known as IR35, applied, because if she had been engaged directly by the BBC on the same terms, she would have been its employee, so that the company was liable for income tax and national insurance. The First-tier Tribunal and the Upper Tribunal held that she would not have been an employee. HMRC appealed, arguing among other things that the tribunals had wrongly taken into account her business activities outside her engagement with the BBC.
Legal principle
The Court of Appeal allowed HMRC's appeal and sent the case back to the First-tier Tribunal. The question under the intermediaries legislation is whether the hypothetical contract between the worker and the client would have been a contract of employment, and the Upper Tribunal had wrongly assessed that question by reference to Ms Adams' wider history of freelance work, rather than the terms of the hypothetical contract with the BBC. A person can be employed and self employed at the same time, and the worker's other activities are relevant only so far as they were known, or could reasonably have been known, to both parties. The court also explained that mutuality and control are necessary conditions of employment but do not create a presumption of it. On reconsideration, the tribunal held in 2023 that the hypothetical contract would not have been one of employment.
Related cases on income and corporation tax: employment, trading and residence
- British Insulated and Helsby Cables Ltd v Atherton [1926] AC 205
- De Beers Consolidated Mines Ltd v Howe [1906] AC 455
- Edwards v Bairstow [1956] AC 14
- Hochstrasser v Mayes [1960] AC 376
- Jones v Garnett [2007] UKHL 35
- Laidler v Perry [1966] AC 16
- Levene v Inland Revenue Commissioners [1928] AC 217
- Mallalieu v Drummond [1983] 2 AC 861
Studying tax law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
