R (Hely-Hutchinson) v Revenue and Customs Commissioners
HMRC was entitled to withdraw published guidance on the tax treatment of share options and apply the law correctly to earlier transactions, because its departure from the guidance was not so unfair as to amount to an abuse of power.
Facts
HMRC had published guidance about the calculation of capital gains on shares acquired through employee share options, which followed a decision of the Court of Appeal. HMRC later concluded that its interpretation had been wrong and that the guidance was too favourable to taxpayers, and it withdrew the guidance and applied the correct law to tax years for which returns had already been filed but could still be amended. Mr Hely-Hutchinson, who had relied on the guidance in claiming a capital loss, argued that HMRC's decision to depart from the guidance in his case was unlawful because it frustrated his legitimate expectation.
Legal principle
The Court of Appeal held that HMRC had acted lawfully. Arden LJ said that a public authority may resile from a representation which has given rise to a legitimate expectation if it is fair to do so, having regard to the public interest. HMRC had a duty to collect the tax due under the law, and the public interest in ensuring that taxpayers paid the correct amount of tax outweighed the unfairness to Mr Hely-Hutchinson, who had not suffered any detriment other than having to pay the tax properly due. HMRC's decision was not so conspicuously unfair as to amount to an abuse of power, and the court distinguished Unilever.
Related cases on tax administration, HMRC powers and taxpayer remedies
- Deutsche Morgan Grenfell Group plc v Inland Revenue Commissioners [2006] UKHL 49, [2007] 1 AC 558
- Fleming (t/a Bodycraft) v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2008] UKHL 2
- Investment Trust Companies v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2017] UKSC 29, [2018] AC 275
- Perrin v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2018] UKUT 156 (TCC)
- Prudential Assurance Co Ltd v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2018] UKSC 39, [2019] AC 929
- R (Haworth) v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2021] UKSC 25
- R (Prudential plc) v Special Commissioner of Income Tax [2013] UKSC 1, [2013] 2 AC 185
- R (Rowe) v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2017] EWCA Civ 2105
Studying tax law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
