Plama Consortium Ltd v Republic of Bulgaria
A most favoured nation clause cannot be used to create consent to arbitration which the basic treaty does not contain, and a denial of benefits clause in the Energy Charter Treaty operates only when the state invokes it.
Facts
Plama, a company incorporated in Cyprus, bought a Bulgarian oil refinery and claimed that Bulgaria had interfered with its investment. It brought a claim under the Energy Charter Treaty and also sought to rely on the most favoured nation clause in the Bulgaria Cyprus bilateral investment treaty, which provided only for limited arbitration on the amount of compensation for expropriation, in order to import the broader consent to ICSID arbitration found in Bulgaria's treaty with Finland. Bulgaria also invoked the denial of benefits clause in article 17 of the Energy Charter Treaty, arguing that Plama was owned by a national of a non contracting state and had no substantial business activities in Cyprus.
Legal principle
The tribunal held that it had jurisdiction under the Energy Charter Treaty, but not under the most favoured nation clause. An agreement to arbitrate must be clear and unambiguous, and a most favoured nation clause in a basic treaty does not incorporate by reference dispute settlement provisions set out in another treaty unless the clause leaves no doubt that the parties intended to do so. The tribunal disagreed with the reasoning in Maffezini v Kingdom of Spain. As to article 17, the right to deny the benefits of the treaty had to be exercised by the state, and operated only prospectively from the date of exercise. In its later award on the merits, the tribunal held that Plama's investment had been obtained by deliberate misrepresentation and was not protected by the treaty.
Related cases on non discrimination, most favoured nation treatment and umbrella clauses
- Maffezini v Kingdom of Spain ICSID Case No ARB/97/7, Decision on Jurisdiction (2000)
- SD Myers Inc v Government of Canada NAFTA Partial Award (2000)
- SGS Société Générale de Surveillance SA v Islamic Republic of Pakistan ICSID Case No ARB/01/13, Decision on Jurisdiction (2003)
- SGS Société Générale de Surveillance SA v Republic of the Philippines ICSID Case No ARB/02/6, Decision on Jurisdiction (2004)
- White Industries Australia Ltd v Republic of India UNCITRAL Final Award (2011)
Studying international investment law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
