Minister voor Immigratie en Asiel v X, Y and Z
Gay people may form a particular social group, and while criminalisation of homosexual acts is not in itself persecution, a term of imprisonment which is actually applied is, and applicants cannot be expected to conceal their sexuality.
Facts
Three men from Sierra Leone, Uganda and Senegal applied for asylum in the Netherlands on the ground that they feared persecution because of their homosexuality. In each of those countries, homosexual acts were criminal offences, punishable by heavy sentences including imprisonment. The Dutch Council of State asked the Court of Justice whether homosexuals could constitute a particular social group under the Qualification Directive, when criminalisation would amount to persecution, and whether applicants could be expected to conceal their sexual orientation or exercise restraint in expressing it.
Legal principle
The Court of Justice held that the existence of criminal laws specifically targeting homosexuals supports a finding that they form a particular social group, because they are perceived as different by the surrounding society. The mere existence of legislation criminalising homosexual acts does not constitute persecution, but a term of imprisonment which sanctions homosexual acts and is actually applied in the country of origin must be regarded as a disproportionate or discriminatory punishment amounting to persecution. When assessing an application, the authorities cannot reasonably expect the applicant to conceal his homosexuality or exercise restraint in expressing it to avoid persecution. The ruling is consistent with HJ (Iran) in the United Kingdom.
Related cases on refugee status and asylum
- AH (Sudan) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2007] UKHL 49
- Al-Sirri v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2012] UKSC 54, [2013] 1 AC 745
- Bolbol v Bevándorlási és Állampolgársági Hivatal Case C-31/09, [2010] ECR I-5539
- Bundesrepublik Deutschland v B and D Joined Cases C-57/09 and C-101/09, [2010] ECR I-10979
- Bundesrepublik Deutschland v Y and Z Joined Cases C-71/11 and C-99/11, EU:C:2012:518
- Canada (Attorney General) v Ward [1993] 2 SCR 689
- Elgafaji v Staatssecretaris van Justitie Case C-465/07, [2009] ECR I-921
- Fornah v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2006] UKHL 46, [2007] 1 AC 412
Studying immigration and asylum law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
