Midland Mainline Ltd v Eagle Star Insurance Co Ltd

Train operating companies could not recover business interruption losses caused by nationwide speed restrictions after the Hatfield crash, because the restrictions resulted from wear and tear to the rails, which was excluded.

Citation
[2004] EWCA Civ 1042
Court
Court of Appeal
Year
2004
Subject
Insurance Law
Topic
Coverage, causation, claims and subrogation

Facts

In October 2000 a train derailed at Hatfield because a rail had fractured as a result of gauge corner cracking, a form of rolling contact fatigue. Railtrack then imposed emergency speed restrictions across the national network while rails were inspected and replaced, causing massive disruption. Several train operating companies claimed under their business interruption insurance for their losses, which they argued were caused by the imposition of the speed restrictions. The insurers relied on exclusions for losses caused by wear and tear and gradual deterioration.

Legal principle

The Court of Appeal held that the exclusion applied. The proximate cause of the losses was the presence of gauge corner cracking in the rails, which was a form of wear and tear and gradual deterioration, rather than the decision to impose the speed restrictions, which was a reasonable and natural response to the cracking. The exclusion was not limited to wear and tear of the insured's own property, but applied to wear and tear of the property on which the insured's business depended. The case illustrates the importance of identifying the proximate cause when a loss results from a chain of events.

Related cases on coverage, causation, claims and subrogation

Studying insurance law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.

Back to all law cases

This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.

Contact Us

Enquire about our bespoke academic solutions