Hewage v Grampian Health Board
The Supreme Court approved the two stage approach to the burden of proof in discrimination claims, under which the burden shifts to the employer once the claimant has proved facts from which discrimination could be inferred.
Facts
Mrs Hewage, a consultant orthodontist of Sri Lankan origin, worked for Grampian Health Board. After a series of incidents in which she was treated unfavourably by her clinical director and other managers, she resigned and claimed constructive unfair dismissal and race and sex discrimination. The employment tribunal upheld her claims, finding that the burden had shifted to the Board to show that it had not discriminated, and that it had failed to discharge it. The Inner House of the Court of Session allowed the Board's appeal.
Legal principle
The Supreme Court, in a judgment given by Lord Hope, unanimously allowed Mrs Hewage's appeal and restored the tribunal's decision. It approved the guidance given by the Court of Appeal in Igen Ltd v Wong and Madarassy v Nomura International plc on the burden of proof, under which the claimant must first prove facts from which the tribunal could conclude, in the absence of an adequate explanation, that the employer had committed an act of discrimination, after which the burden shifts to the employer to prove that it did not. Lord Hope said that the burden of proof provisions will require careful attention where there is room for doubt as to the facts necessary to establish discrimination, but have nothing to offer where the tribunal is in a position to make positive findings on the evidence one way or the other. The tribunal had been entitled to find that the burden had shifted.
Related cases on discrimination at work
- Achbita v G4S Secure Solutions NV Case C-157/15, EU:C:2017:203
- Archibald v Fife Council [2004] UKHL 32, [2004] ICR 954
- Bougnaoui v Micropole SA Case C-188/15, EU:C:2017:204
- Bull v Hall [2013] UKSC 73
- Chief Constable of the West Yorkshire Police v Khan [2001] UKHL 48, [2001] 1 WLR 1947
- Coleman v Attridge Law Case C-303/06, [2008] ECR I-5603
- Dekker v Stichting Vormingscentrum voor Jong Volwassenen Plus Case C-177/88, [1990] ECR I-3941
- Essop v Home Office (UK Border Agency) [2017] UKSC 27, [2017] 1 WLR 1343
Studying employment law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
