Hall Street Associates LLC v Mattel Inc
The grounds in the Federal Arbitration Act for vacating or modifying an arbitration award are exclusive, so parties cannot agree to expand judicial review of awards to include errors of law.
Facts
Hall Street, a landlord, and Mattel, its tenant, became involved in a dispute about Mattel's obligation to indemnify Hall Street for environmental cleanup costs on the leased property. During court proceedings, they agreed to submit the indemnification issue to arbitration, on terms that the court would vacate, modify or correct any award where the arbitrator's conclusions of law were erroneous. The arbitrator decided in Mattel's favour, and the district court, applying the agreement, vacated the award for an error of law. The question was whether the parties could validly agree to such expanded review.
Legal principle
The US Supreme Court held by a majority that the statutory grounds for vacatur and modification in sections 10 and 11 of the Federal Arbitration Act are exclusive, and cannot be supplemented by contract. Souter J said that the provisions address egregious departures from the parties' agreed arbitration, such as corruption, fraud and evident partiality, and that the Act's policy of enforcing arbitration agreements does not extend to allowing parties to expand the grounds of review, which would undermine the national policy favouring arbitration with only limited review. The court left open whether the parties could obtain expanded review through other routes, such as state law.
Related cases on challenging and enforcing awards, and investment arbitration
- BG Group plc v Republic of Argentina 572 US 25 (2014)
- Eco Swiss China Time Ltd v Benetton International NV Case C-126/97, [1999] ECR I-3055
- Federal Republic of Nigeria v Process & Industrial Developments Ltd [2023] EWHC 2638 (Comm)
- IPCO (Nigeria) Ltd v Nigerian National Petroleum Corp [2017] UKSC 16
- Kanoria v Guinness [2006] EWCA Civ 222
- Kingdom of Spain v Infrastructure Services Luxembourg Sàrl [2026] UKSC 9
- Lesotho Highlands Development Authority v Impregilo SpA [2005] UKHL 43, [2006] 1 AC 221
- Micula v Romania [2020] UKSC 5
Studying arbitration? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
