Davidson v Scottish Ministers (No 2)

A judge who had, as a law officer, expressed a view in Parliament about the effect of a statutory provision should not have sat on an appeal about the same issue, because of the appearance of bias.

Citation
[2004] UKHL 34
Court
House of Lords
Year
2004
Subject
English Legal System
Topic
Judiciary, legal profession and access to justice

Facts

Mr Davidson, a prisoner, complained about the conditions in which he was held at Barlinnie Prison, and sought an order against the Scottish Ministers requiring them to move him. The question was whether section 21 of the Crown Proceedings Act 1947 prevented the court from making such an order against the Crown. One of the judges of the Inner House who decided the point, Lord Hardie, had previously, as Lord Advocate, assured the House of Lords during the passage of the Scotland Act 1998 that section 21 would prevent coercive orders against the Scottish Ministers.

Legal principle

The House of Lords held that the decision of the Inner House should be set aside. Lord Bingham said that a fair minded and informed observer would conclude that there was a real possibility that Lord Hardie, having expressed a view on the meaning of section 21 when promoting legislation in Parliament, would subconsciously strive to avoid reaching a conclusion inconsistent with his earlier statements. The test for apparent bias in Porter v Magill was applied. The case shows the importance of separating legislative and judicial functions, and the need for judges to stand down where they have expressed views on the very issue in a different capacity.

Related cases on judiciary, legal profession and access to justice

Studying english legal system? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.

Back to all law cases

This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.

Contact Us

Enquire about our bespoke academic solutions