Compañía de Aguas del Aconquija SA and Vivendi Universal v Argentine Republic
Whether there has been a breach of an investment treaty and whether there has been a breach of contract are different questions, so a contractual forum clause cannot prevent a tribunal from deciding treaty claims.
Facts
A French company and its Argentine affiliate held a concession for water and sewerage services in the Argentine province of Tucumán. They claimed that the province had undermined the concession by measures including political campaigning against tariffs, and brought a claim under the France Argentina bilateral investment treaty. The concession contract gave exclusive jurisdiction to the courts of Tucumán. The original tribunal dismissed the claims, holding that, because they were closely linked to the performance of the contract, they had to be pursued first in the Tucumán courts.
Legal principle
The ad hoc annulment committee annulled the part of the award which dismissed the claims relating to the province's conduct, holding that the tribunal had manifestly exceeded its powers by failing to decide the treaty claims. Whether there has been a breach of a treaty and whether there has been a breach of contract are different questions, each determined by reference to its own proper law, the treaty being governed by international law and the contract by its own law. A state may breach a treaty without breaching a contract, and vice versa, and an exclusive jurisdiction clause in a contract cannot operate to exclude a tribunal's jurisdiction over a claim based on a treaty. The claims were resubmitted to a new tribunal, which in 2007 found breaches of the treaty and awarded substantial damages. The decision is a leading authority on the distinction between treaty and contract claims.
Related cases on annulment, enforcement and compensation
- Biwater Gauff (Tanzania) Ltd v United Republic of Tanzania ICSID Case No ARB/05/22, Award (2008)
- Eiser Infrastructure Ltd v Kingdom of Spain ICSID Case No ARB/13/36, Decision on Annulment (2020)
- Factory at Chorzów (Germany v Poland) (1928) PCIJ Series A No 17
- Kingdom of Spain v Infrastructure Services Luxembourg Sàrl [2026] UKSC 9
- Klöckner Industrie-Anlagen GmbH v United Republic of Cameroon ICSID Case No ARB/81/2, Decision on Annulment (1985)
- Micula v Romania [2020] UKSC 5
- Republic of Ecuador v Occidental Exploration and Production Co [2005] EWCA Civ 1116, [2006] QB 432
Studying international investment law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
