CMS Gas Transmission Co v Argentine Republic

Argentina's emergency measures during its 2001 economic crisis breached the fair and equitable treatment standard, and its defence of necessity failed because the measures were not the only way to respond and Argentina had contributed to the crisis.

Citation
ICSID Case No ARB/01/8, Award (2005)
Court
ICSID Tribunal
Year
2005
Subject
International Investment Law
Topic
State defences, the right to regulate and investor obligations

Facts

CMS, a United States company, bought a minority shareholding in TGN, an Argentine gas transportation company, after Argentina privatised its gas industry. The licence allowed TGN to calculate its tariffs in US dollars and to adjust them in line with the United States producer price index. During its severe economic crisis in 2001 and 2002, Argentina converted the tariffs into pesos at a rate of one to one and froze them. CMS brought a claim under the United States Argentina bilateral investment treaty, and Argentina relied on the defence of necessity under customary international law and on article XI of the treaty, which allowed measures necessary for the maintenance of public order or the protection of essential security interests.

Legal principle

The tribunal held that Argentina had breached the fair and equitable treatment standard by fundamentally altering the legal and business framework on which the investment had been made, and the umbrella clause, but that there had been no expropriation. The defence of necessity, as set out in article 25 of the International Law Commission's Articles on State Responsibility, failed because the measures were not the only way for Argentina to safeguard its essential interests and Argentina had contributed to the situation of necessity, and article XI was interpreted by reference to the same customary requirements. CMS was awarded about 133 million US dollars. An ad hoc annulment committee later criticised the tribunal for treating article XI as equivalent to customary necessity, which it regarded as a manifest error of law, but annulled only the finding on the umbrella clause, so the award of damages stood.

Related cases on state defences, the right to regulate and investor obligations

Studying international investment law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.

Back to all law cases

This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.

Contact Us

Enquire about our bespoke academic solutions