Bilcon of Delaware Inc v Government of Canada
Canada breached the minimum standard of treatment and national treatment when an environmental review panel recommended rejecting a quarry on the basis of community core values, a standard not found in the applicable law.
Facts
Bilcon, a United States company, proposed to build a quarry and marine terminal at Whites Point in Nova Scotia. The project was referred to a joint federal and provincial environmental review panel, which recommended that it be rejected, mainly because it was inconsistent with the core values of the local community, and the governments accepted the recommendation. Bilcon claimed under Chapter 11 of NAFTA that it had been encouraged to invest by government officials and then treated unfairly.
Legal principle
The tribunal, by a majority, held that Canada had breached the minimum standard of treatment in article 1105 and the national treatment obligation in article 1102. The panel had effectively created a new standard of community core values, which was not authorised by the applicable environmental assessment law, and had failed to carry out the required assessment of the project's likely effects and of possible mitigation measures, so the investor had not been treated in accordance with the law. Professor Donald McRae dissented, warning that the decision would create a chill on environmental review by giving investors a remedy for decisions that should be challenged in domestic courts. The case is controversial in the debate about investment arbitration and environmental regulation.
Related cases on fair and equitable treatment and full protection and security
- American Manufacturing & Trading Inc v Republic of Zaire ICSID Case No ARB/93/1, Award (1997)
- Asian Agricultural Products Ltd v Republic of Sri Lanka ICSID Case No ARB/87/3, Award (1990)
- Chevron Corp and Texaco Petroleum Co v Republic of Ecuador (No 2) PCA Case No 2009-23, Second Partial Award on Track II (2018)
- Elettronica Sicula SpA (ELSI) (United States of America v Italy) (1989) ICJ Reports 15
- Glamis Gold Ltd v United States of America NAFTA Award (2009)
- LFH Neer and Pauline Neer (United States v United Mexican States) (1926) 4 RIAA 60
- Loewen Group Inc v United States of America ICSID Case No ARB(AF)/98/3, Award (2003)
- Pope & Talbot Inc v Government of Canada NAFTA Award on the Merits of Phase 2 (2001)
Studying international investment law? Our tutors help you understand and apply cases like this in essays, problem questions and exams. Request a quote or browse our law notes.
This summary is for study and revision and is not legal advice. Although our case summaries are checked for accuracy, we do not guarantee that they are free from errors or omissions. Always read the full judgment for the court's reasoning.
